Saline or silicone?

bb8 · 10-07-2009, 08:53 AM

My breast augmentation date is Nov. 3 and I have been really torn between saline or silicone. I know silicone is supposed to feel more natural but I worry about having to get MRI's every couple of years or getting sick from the silicone. But I've heard silicone implants have been greatly improved. On the other hand I worry saline unders won't feel natural to me or my husband. I'm so torn. Any input would be really appreciated.

Mrs · 10-07-2009, 09:01 AM

do some looking on youtube for videos on silicone and saline implants. i found it very helpfull!
i dont think you could get sick from the silicone - the old style silicone yes but not the new.
there are pro's and con's on both sides, so you need to weigh up what is best for you.

good luck!!

bb8 · 10-07-2009, 09:07 AM

Thanks! I'll check out youtube. Do you think the fears with silicone is an american thing? Do you find less women are concerned about this in Australia or do you think it's about the same?

hairgirl · 10-07-2009, 10:10 AM

The new silicone is not the same as the old & saline still has a silicone shell. My PS & the 2 others I saw all told me that the US is the only country that still uses silicone. You have to do your research & find whats best for you. I have silicone & at 5months they feel so natural, but other who have saline have said the same. alot depends on how much natural breast tissue you have, I didn't have any so the chances of rippling were higher w/ me if I chose saline. I personally waited to get my breast augmentation done until silicone was available again, I never wanted saline.
hth

jadecat · 10-07-2009, 06:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bb8

Thanks! I'll check out youtube. Do you think the fears with silicone is an american thing? Do you find less women are concerned about this in Australia or do you think it's about the same?

hey im australian and ova here 98% of breast augmentation are silicone and PS dont like doing saline due to rippling and silicone feeling more natural but i still worry about silicone. and sory i dont know what u mean when u say US is the only country that uses silicone. i know UK is same as australia they both almost always use silicone and very rarely do saline

sncobb · 10-07-2009, 07:41 PM

I'm getting silicone because I have little to no breast tissue left after breast feeding to boys, but I wanted silicone because it suppose to feel and look more natural than saline. Good Luck!

vezousk · 10-07-2009, 08:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bb8

Thanks! I'll check out youtube. Do you think the fears with silicone is an american thing? Do you find less women are concerned about this in Australia or do you think it's about the same?

Hi, I am in Canada here and this silicone stigma is definitely American imo. I have no fear whatsoever wrt my silicones (made by Mentor) and got them because they were highly recommended by my surgeon, who affirmed that 95% of his BAs are done using silicone...

Mrs · 10-07-2009, 10:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bb8

Thanks! I'll check out youtube. Do you think the fears with silicone is an american thing? Do you find less women are concerned about this in Australia or do you think it's about the same?

Silicone is used A LOT over here, it would harder to find someone to do saline.
But in saying that, many people aren't aware that the new silicone is completly different from the old.

bb8 · 10-08-2009, 07:25 AM

Now I'm leaning towards silicone. I better make up my mind one way or the other as my surgery date is Nov. 3rd. Thank you all so much for letting me know what you think.

LadyS · 10-08-2009, 07:31 PM

Hey!!
I know you've already heard this from the other Aussie Ladies, but the first PS i went to havent used Saline in over 8 years.. Barely anywhere has the option to go with Saline here. Silicone has been greatly improved over the years

IMO - definitely the way to go..
HTH!

bb8 · 10-08-2009, 08:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LadyS

Hey!!
I know you've already heard this from the other Aussie Ladies, but the first PS i went to havent used Saline in over 8 years.. Barely anywhere has the option to go with Saline here. Silicone has been greatly improved over the years

IMO - definitely the way to go..
HTH!

Thanks for your thoughts. It's really been a difficult decision b/c the US still uses saline a lot but I made the decision today to go with silicone.

yngscrooge · 10-09-2009, 01:06 AM

After doing research IMO silicone is soo much safer than saline. I have no fear of having silicone implants. On top of that, it feels and looks so much more natural than the majority of saline imlants. My PS encouraged me to use silicone and said "BAs have been looking so much better since silicone came back on the market."

yngscrooge · 10-09-2009, 01:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hairgirl

The new silicone is not the same as the old & saline still has a silicone shell. My PS & the 2 others I saw all told me that the US is the only country that still uses silicone. You have to do your research & find whats best for you. I have silicone & at 5months they feel so natural, but other who have saline have said the same. alot depends on how much natural breast tissue you have, I didn't have any so the chances of rippling were higher w/ me if I chose saline. I personally waited to get my breast augmentation done until silicone was available again, I never wanted saline.
hth

I think hairgirl means that the US is the only country still using saline NOT silicone. Just a typo

bb8 · 10-09-2009, 10:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by yngscrooge

I think hairgirl means that the US is the only country still using saline NOT silicone. Just a typo

Definitely a typo. I slept on it last night and still feel good about going with silicone. I called the office this morning and made the switch. There is still a stigma with silicone but everything I research about it makes me think its just that - bad vibes from the past that aren't relevant anymore. That's just my opinion. I'm going to go with my gut. What about mri's? Do any of you get mri's periodically to make sure there is no rupture? Thanks again everyone!!!

Shazza · 10-09-2009, 12:43 PM

I need to make the choice soon too. I am in BC, Canada, and the one ps I am going to said that the majority of his patients still choose saline, however, *he* prefers to use silicone.

From an esthetics point of view, I prefer silicone, but I do have concerns about rupture. I have seen the video (some good ones on here), but since the silicone is so gummy like, I wonder how long a rupture will go unnoticed and if undetected, what harm even teeny bits of silicone can have. I have a consult on Oct 21, so I will be grilling the ps about it. I really hope that I am satisfied with his answers, b/c I want silicone!

I am a bit relieved to find out silicone is pretty much the choice in Australia and Europe.

I am not going to have my breast augmentation until early in the new year (hopefully Feb!!), so I still have time to decide.

Good luck on your choice.

Shaz

gobigorgohome · 10-09-2009, 02:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bb8

My breast augmentation date is Nov. 3 and I have been really torn between saline or silicone. I know silicone is supposed to feel more natural but I worry about having to get MRI's every couple of years or getting sick from the silicone. But I've heard silicone implants have been greatly improved. On the other hand I worry saline unders won't feel natural to me or my husband. I'm so torn. Any input would be really appreciated.

I have saline right now, and I love the look, but I can definetely feel the difference when I felt a friend's who got silicone. They just felt totally natural. I am going to switch to silicone when I go bigger. I was initially worried about the silicone implants as well, but after hearing from so many people that they are safe, I would go with them now.

bb8 · 10-09-2009, 04:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gobigorgohome

I have saline right now, and I love the look, but I can definetely feel the difference when I felt a friend's who got silicone. They just felt totally natural. I am going to switch to silicone when I go bigger. I was initially worried about the silicone implants as well, but after hearing from so many people that they are safe, I would go with them now.

Thanks for some input from the saline side! I'm glad to hear even though you can notice a difference with your friend's, that you are still happy with yours. I do wish I was getting this done like a decade from now after there has been more research done but I can't wait 10 years! One thing I do know for sure is whichever I choose I'll be happy to have bigger boobies! I've had A cup breasts with this curvy body for way too long!

Madisyn · 10-09-2009, 11:11 PM

I have had both. I had salines for 10 years and in July I switched to silicone and the difference is HUGE! They feel fantastic!!! You will love the silicone implants.

PDS · 10-09-2009, 11:29 PM

My PS says silicone is so much better than saline. And if you're not at risk for breast cancer, then it's a definite must! He also said that I could go 7 years before I get an MRI and that the 3 year thing was just a precaution from the manufacturer being extra cautious as to not get sued! Definitely go with silicone! I hear it's worth all the money! And its what I'm getting two months from tomorrow!!! Yay!

ILTSOY05 · 10-10-2009, 07:02 PM

I have silicone and love it.. I was dead set on saline in the beginning, but after much research, talking to my PS and talking to people who had both, I went with sils.. I can deal with having an MRI done... I think the thing I liked most aside from how sils felt in comparison to saline was that my implants were going in already filled, unlike saline, which has a self sealing valve due to being filled during surgery. I knew that the rupture rate was slim to none with sils.. I think you'd basically have to stab/slice me in the boob with a butcher knife to puncture them... Another deciding factor was my cousin, who because of complications had to have a revision.. she began her breast augmentation with saline, but during her last revision switched to sils.. She said there is a world of difference and she wished she had gone with sils from the get-go.

Each lady will be an advocate for her type of implant.. I prefer sils, but the next lady may prefer saline.. Make judgement based on how YOU feel after researching and talking to anyone and everyone you can!

10-07-2009, 08:53 AM	#1
bb8 Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: chicago, illinois Posts: 116 Thanks: 37 Thanked 40 Times in 35 Posts	Saline or silicone? My breast augmentation date is Nov. 3 and I have been really torn between saline or silicone. I know silicone is supposed to feel more natural but I worry about having to get MRI's every couple of years or getting sick from the silicone. But I've heard silicone implants have been greatly improved. On the other hand I worry saline unders won't feel natural to me or my husband. I'm so torn. Any input would be really appreciated.

10-07-2009, 10:10 AM	#4
hairgirl "Life ain't always beautiful, but it's a beautiful ride" Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: arizona Posts: 643 Thanks: 104 Thanked 252 Times in 221 Posts	The new silicone is not the same as the old & saline still has a silicone shell. My PS & the 2 others I saw all told me that the US is the only country that still uses silicone. You have to do your research & find whats best for you. I have silicone & at 5months they feel so natural, but other who have saline have said the same. alot depends on how much natural breast tissue you have, I didn't have any so the chances of rippling were higher w/ me if I chose saline. I personally waited to get my breast augmentation done until silicone was available again, I never wanted saline. hth __________________ DR. MEGER 5'7 135lbs 36 saggy a/b 36DDD 500hp silicone/full anchor lift, aereola reduction YOU MUST SEND A NOTE 1ST & be getting or already have a lift

10-07-2009, 07:41 PM	#6
sncobb Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: columbus georgia Posts: 260 Thanks: 179 Thanked 79 Times in 77 Posts	I'm getting silicone because I have little to no breast tissue left after breast feeding to boys, but I wanted silicone because it suppose to feel and look more natural than saline. Good Luck! __________________

10-08-2009, 07:25 AM	#9
bb8 Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: chicago, illinois Posts: 116 Thanks: 37 Thanked 40 Times in 35 Posts	Thanks to everyone for their input Now I'm leaning towards silicone. I better make up my mind one way or the other as my surgery date is Nov. 3rd. Thank you all so much for letting me know what you think.

10-09-2009, 01:06 AM	#12
yngscrooge Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: Alexandria, Virginia Posts: 76 Thanks: 1 Thanked 19 Times in 19 Posts	After doing research IMO silicone is soo much safer than saline. I have no fear of having silicone implants. On top of that, it feels and looks so much more natural than the majority of saline imlants. My PS encouraged me to use silicone and said "BAs have been looking so much better since silicone came back on the market." __________________ -

10-07-2009, 09:01 AM	#2
Mrs Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: Australia. Posts: 138 Thanks: 5 Thanked 55 Times in 47 Posts	do some looking on youtube for videos on silicone and saline implants. i found it very helpfull! i dont think you could get sick from the silicone - the old style silicone yes but not the new. there are pro's and con's on both sides, so you need to weigh up what is best for you. good luck!!

10-07-2009, 09:07 AM	#3
bb8 Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: chicago, illinois Posts: 116 Thanks: 37 Thanked 40 Times in 35 Posts	Thanks! I'll check out youtube. Do you think the fears with silicone is an american thing? Do you find less women are concerned about this in Australia or do you think it's about the same?

10-08-2009, 07:31 PM	#10
LadyS Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: Sydney, Australia Posts: 38 Thanks: 62 Thanked 3 Times in 3 Posts	Hey!! I know you've already heard this from the other Aussie Ladies, but the first PS i went to havent used Saline in over 8 years.. Barely anywhere has the option to go with Saline here. Silicone has been greatly improved over the years IMO - definitely the way to go.. HTH!

10-09-2009, 12:43 PM	#15
Shazza Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: Surrey, BC Posts: 119 Thanks: 48 Thanked 27 Times in 24 Posts	Me too! I need to make the choice soon too. I am in BC, Canada, and the one ps I am going to said that the majority of his patients still choose saline, however, he prefers to use silicone. From an esthetics point of view, I prefer silicone, but I do have concerns about rupture. I have seen the video (some good ones on here), but since the silicone is so gummy like, I wonder how long a rupture will go unnoticed and if undetected, what harm even teeny bits of silicone can have. I have a consult on Oct 21, so I will be grilling the ps about it. I really hope that I am satisfied with his answers, b/c I want silicone! I am a bit relieved to find out silicone is pretty much the choice in Australia and Europe. I am not going to have my breast augmentation until early in the new year (hopefully Feb!!), so I still have time to decide. Good luck on your choice. Shaz

10-09-2009, 11:11 PM	#18
Madisyn Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: tracy, california Posts: 11 Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts	I have had both. I had salines for 10 years and in July I switched to silicone and the difference is HUGE! They feel fantastic!!! You will love the silicone implants.

10-09-2009, 11:29 PM	#19
PDS Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: Irvine, California Posts: 132 Thanks: 23 Thanked 37 Times in 34 Posts	My PS says silicone is so much better than saline. And if you're not at risk for breast cancer, then it's a definite must! He also said that I could go 7 years before I get an MRI and that the 3 year thing was just a precaution from the manufacturer being extra cautious as to not get sued! Definitely go with silicone! I hear it's worth all the money! And its what I'm getting two months from tomorrow!!! Yay! __________________ Pre breast augmentation: full 34A Post breast augmentation: 34D and still more D&F to come! Implants: Natrelle Silicone Gel Moderate Profile - 339cc Placement:Complete Unders Incision: Areola breast augmentation Date: December 10, 2009! Can't believe I have BOOBS!

10-10-2009, 07:02 PM	#20
ILTSOY05 "This ain't your mama's silicone..." Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: South Carolina Posts: 502 Thanks: 188 Thanked 236 Times in 171 Posts	I have silicone and love it.. I was dead set on saline in the beginning, but after much research, talking to my PS and talking to people who had both, I went with sils.. I can deal with having an MRI done... I think the thing I liked most aside from how sils felt in comparison to saline was that my implants were going in already filled, unlike saline, which has a self sealing valve due to being filled during surgery. I knew that the rupture rate was slim to none with sils.. I think you'd basically have to stab/slice me in the boob with a butcher knife to puncture them... Another deciding factor was my cousin, who because of complications had to have a revision.. she began her breast augmentation with saline, but during her last revision switched to sils.. She said there is a world of difference and she wished she had gone with sils from the get-go. Each lady will be an advocate for her type of implant.. I prefer sils, but the next lady may prefer saline.. Make judgement based on how YOU feel after researching and talking to anyone and everyone you can! __________________ Mentor HP/600cc/Silicone/Unders/Crease Surgery Date: April 30, 2009 Pre-Op: 36A/B Post-Op: 36DD/34E 5'7"/160lbs *For personal and privacy reasons: Friend requests from ELITE members ONLY*

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
If you have silicone cohesive gels -	iluvmydog66	General Breast Augmentation Discussion	27	10-26-2009 01:40 PM
Silicone OR Saline? Which is better, pros/cons	Bunni	General Breast Augmentation Discussion	20	09-07-2009 02:00 PM
Form stable silicone vs saline - wondering about feel	Summer7	General Breast Augmentation Discussion	6	06-16-2009 09:49 AM
Saline or silicone	nickyfourfatima	General Breast Augmentation Discussion	11	02-12-2007 10:10 PM
Set me straight about silicone....long	jeansie	General Breast Augmentation Discussion	15	01-15-2007 10:57 PM