Has anyone had this done? My surgeon recommended it but I'd like to hear your thoughts on it.

I dont know about that. I'd be a little leery of that in the lips.

The Permasil Lip Implants are probably a more reliable option. THey are permanent, but if you don't like them they can be taken out. THey are thin silicone tubules that are channeled through your lip for fullness. They look great!!!

I haven't heard of those before. I originally wanted lip implants because they're permanent, but I heard that they feel hard and unnatural. That may just be the Gore-Tex implants though.

I come from Eastern Europe and we are not able to get permanent implants like Advanta, Permasil,... So surgeons often use scares or skin from somewhere on the body for permanent lip augmentation. Alloderm is just like that you just use skin of a donor. But some women can have psychological problems with it. To be honest I am also not sure I could be happy knowing I have some skin from a dead person in my lips.